This is a different question from "my tree is too big", and it is worth separating. A tree that is too big can be made smaller. A tree that has outgrown its *position* is in the wrong place, and making it smaller only postpones the conversation.
Which one do you have?
| Situation | What it is | Answer |
|---|---|---|
| Large, but there is room around it | Too big | Reduction — a one-off |
| Large, and pressing on things in every direction | Outgrown its position | Recurring reduction, or replace |
| Trunk against a wall, fence or building | Outgrown its position | Removal conversation |
| Roots lifting paving or a drive | Depends on the tree's value | Root pruning, relaying, or removal |
| Canopy over the whole garden | Could be either | Lift and thin first, then judge |
Do the arithmetic honestly
A sensible reduction takes a quarter to a third of the crown and holds three to five years on a healthy broadleaf. On a genuinely out-of-scale tree that means booking a reduction roughly every four years, indefinitely.
Over twenty years that is five reductions. Set against a single removal plus a replacement tree that suits the position, the comparison is not obvious either way — and it depends entirely on what the tree is worth to you.
What the tree is worth is a real factor, not a sentimental one
- Screening. Frequently more than people realise, and a fence is generally limited to two metres under permitted development.
- Shade. Noticed most in the summer after it has gone.
- The look of the garden. A mature tree takes decades to replace.
- Wildlife and character. Genuine, and worth weighing.
- Whether it is protected, which may settle the question for you.
It is worth standing in the garden and looking at what you would be able to see, and what the space would feel like, if the tree were not there. People frequently discover it is doing more work than they had noticed.
Working around it instead
Sometimes the honest answer is neither reduction nor removal but changing what is around the tree — and this is the option that gets least consideration.
- Move the shed or greenhouse rather than keep pruning over it.
- Relay the paving the roots have lifted, with a flexible surface or a gap around the trunk.
- Redesign that part of the garden as shade planting rather than fighting for sun.
- Lift the canopy and use the ground underneath rather than resenting the tree for occupying it.
- Reroute a path around the root plate rather than through it.
When removal is genuinely the answer
- The trunk is physically against a building or a structural wall.
- The tree is structurally unsound as well as badly placed.
- It is a forest species in a small garden and the recurring cost is not worth carrying.
- The garden is being comprehensively redesigned and it does not fit the plan.
- It was badly topped in the past and will never make a decent shape.
The permission dimension may decide it
Worth establishing before anything else. Stourport's conservation area covers the canal basin and the streets around it, and a tree within it needs six weeks' written notice to Wyre Forest District Council. Give notice of an intention to fell a prominent healthy tree and the council may respond by making a Tree Preservation Order — which is exactly what that window exists for.
A tree that already carries a TPO needs a formal consent application, normally decided within eight weeks, with a right of appeal. Consent frequently comes with a replanting condition.
A notice for a sensible reduction on a sound tree usually passes without comment. So if what you actually need is a smaller tree, proposing that rather than removal is both cheaper and considerably more likely to happen.
If you do replace it
Choose for the position rather than for the look at planting size. The reason so many gardens have out-of-scale trees is that they were bought as three-foot specimens without much thought about forty-foot ones.
And if you are replanting in the same spot, note that some species suffer replant disease — moving the new tree a few metres, or changing the soil in the planting pit, is the usual answer.
Got a tree in the wrong place?
Tell us what it is and what it's too close to. We'll give you an honest view of the options.
More Stourport-on-Severn Tree Surgery Guides
Also in Stourport-on-Severn
Tree Surgery in Stourport-on-Severn →
Hedge Maintenance in Stourport-on-Severn →
All tree surgery guides →